The Sayville Inn

Nestled in the heart of Sayville, NY, The Sayville Inn stands out as a warm and inviting restaurant and bar that effortlessly blends classic comfort with delightful culinary innovation. This local gem offers an eclectic American menu with special touches that showcase fresh ingredients and bold flavors, making it a must-visit for both residents and visitors.

The moment you step inside, the inviting, lively atmosphere sets the tone for a truly enjoyable dining experience. Whether you’re catching the game with friends over a cold Stella Artois draft or settling in for a cozy dinner, the vibe is relaxed and welcoming, embodying that “lived-in” charm reviewers rave about. Friendly, attentive staff contribute to the experience, making you feel right at home.

The menu is a treasure trove of mouthwatering options that cater to a range of cravings. Among the standout dishes, the French Onion Soup is deeply savory, topped with melted cheese that perfectly complements its rich broth. Seafood lovers will find joy in the PEI Mussels, steamy and tender, or the Sayville Tacos — particularly the Baja Fish Tacos, boasting a crispy coconut beer batter encasing fresh fish, paired with vibrant pico de gallo and chipotle slaw for an irresistible balance of flavors and textures.

Meat lovers can indulge in the Short Rib French Dip Flatbread, where succulent beef melds with melted cheese and a savory dip, or the juicy Middle Road Burger. For those seeking something lighter yet equally satisfying, the Corn Salad and Eggplant Towers offer creative vegetable-forward choices bursting with freshness.

The drink menu complements the food expertly, with a thoughtfully curated selection of draft beers, including the crisp and refreshing Stella Artois. Signature cocktails like the Cosmo and Vodka Gimlet add a polished touch, while the less common but highly praised Cinnamon Whiskey Sour brings a cool, refreshing twist to classic cocktails, perfect for autumn afternoons or game days on the generous outdoor seating patio.

Weekly specials elevate the experience with dishes like the Buffalo Chicken Nachos, layered with mixed cheese, tomato, onion, and bleu cheese crumbles, and the indulgent 12oz Seared Ribeye topped with bleu cheese garlic butter, served alongside creamy garlic mashed potatoes and asparagus. The Teriyaki Glazed Salmon offers a delightful balance of sweet and savory, making every visit feel like a fresh culinary adventure.

Don’t skip dessert — the homemade treats here are heavenly. The Tollhouse Cookie Pie, with its warm, gooey chocolate chip crust and vanilla ice cream drizzled in hot fudge, provides a nostalgic yet luxurious end to any meal. Other delights include the Brownie Chip Sundae and the inventive Rice Krispy Treat Pie, layered with chocolate peanut butter fudge and cookies and cream ice cream, each bite evoking pure comfort and joy.

What truly sets The Sayville Inn apart is the palpable care and passion infused into every aspect of the guest experience — from the thoughtfully prepared food to the attentive staff who make you feel like a valued friend. Guests consistently remark on the friendly service and warm atmosphere, whether they’re gathering for a family celebration in the historic party room or catching up with friends over expertly crafted drinks and great food.

In essence, The Sayville Inn is more than just a place to eat and drink; it’s a community hub where quality, flavor, and genuine hospitality converge. If you’re seeking a restaurant in Sayville that delivers authentic tastes, satisfying portions, and a welcoming environment, this spot deserves a top spot on your must-visit list.

Contact & Location:
199 Middle Rd, Sayville, NY 11782, United States
Phone: +1 631-319-6774